Date: 6/30/25 3:35 pm
From: Chris McCreedy <cristofolos...>
Subject: ESbirds: Wildrose Canyon (Mono) Cooper's Hawk nest, general protocol on eBirding sensitive species
Hi,

eBird has put effort into masking the locations of sensitive species, and
you can read about it here:

https://support.ebird.org/en/support/solutions/articles/48000803210-sensitive-species-in-ebird#Sensitive-Species-List

Also: if you absolutely need to eBird something that is sensitive, you can
1) use a county-level location (.e.g, Mono County). You can also hide your
checklist from public view. You can also wait a few months (at least 2
weeks, anyway) after the sighting before submitting the list. Observations
reported within 2 weeks of the event get broadcast to anyone subscribing to
the county's Needs alerts (species they have not yet ticked) or Rare Bird
alerts (any bird species flagged as rare when you submit a checklist).

There were recent reports of American Goshawk nestlings at Wildrose Canyon
in Mono. A couple things on this. First, it is widely suspected that folks
interested in falconry might be interested in goshawk chicks for their
hobby. Please do not submit checklists of goshawk nest locations, or talk
about nests in your notes. If you submit a list with more than 1 goshawk,
that can draw attention to your location. I have no data for you on how
often goshawk nestlings actually are taken, but it wasn't helpful to
broadcast the presence of nestlings that showed the substrate (the plant
holding the nest). If it is where I think it probably was, it was very
accessible.

In addition, it doesn't seem to me that it was actually a goshawk nest. I
leaned Cooper's Hawk, Hawkwatch staff leaned Cooper's Hawk, and Nora
Livingston confirmed to me that she had observed an adult Cooper's Hawk at
the nest.

There have been other cases of observers posting photos of grouse lek
locations, fledgling owl locations, that sort of thing.

Please understand that 1) if it is a flagged species, though it does not
show on an eBird map before I validate a record, it still will be broadcast
on eBird alerts if you report it within 2 weeks of the sighting. I do not
receive any sort of heads up if it is an unflagged species, or if the count
is not above what I have set to trigger a flag.

Photos that show landscape views will help people triangulate to where you
were. People chase reports, whether they are falconers, hunters, or just
other birders, or people interested in photographing birds. Once you post
it, you have no control over who chases it and how they behave when they
get there.

Thanks for your help with this.

Chris McCreedy
Mono CA and Yuma AZ eBird review

--

---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "EasternSierraBirds" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to easternsierrabirds+<unsubscribe...>
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/easternsierrabirds/CAC5Hsku_3%2Bt_V%2BuPirY5g4no%<3DXyJvggOKwmqPgrn2PbrjX4eEQ...>

 
Join us on Facebook!